Many factors impact home prices in Fayette County
Local real estate agents and appraisers agree that many factors affect the sale price of homes in Fayette County.
“ItĢƵ supply and demand,” said Scott Cavinee, a real estate broker for SWC Properties in Uniontown. “A house is worth what a buyer is willing to pay and what a seller in willing to sell for.”
Every year for the last few years, there have been about 330 to 360 homes for sale in the county, Cavinee said.
A large number of homes on the market can force prices down and a smaller number can push prices up, he said.
Demand increases when the economy is healthy and decreases when times aren’t so good, he said.
Available financing impacts demand, Cavinee said, noting that government-backed home loans are more difficult to obtain now.
“It all goes to supply and demand,” Cavinee said.
Taxes are what buyers consider first followed by the condition and amenities of a home, said Franklin A. John, an appraiser in Uniontown.
“First is taxation. In Uniontown, thereĢƵ 65 homes for sale. The tax in the city is 12.235 (mills),” John said referring to the cityĢƵ real estate tax rate, which does not include school district taxes. “ThatĢƵ got to come down. Where as you move to LH (Laurel Highlands), itĢƵ 60 percent cheaper. It impacts the selling rate.”
He said city provides full-time services that other municipalities don’t, but they come at a cost.
“Of course, Uniontown has a police department and a fire department. You get the amenities, which is good. The city is a fine place to live because you have all the amenities here,” John said.
The condition of bathrooms, the kitchen, windows, roof and heating system are what buyers inspect first when they look at homes, he said.
“If you don’t like the color of the walls, you can change that,” John said. “They appraise higher if you have insulation, public sewage, newer roof and you’re not in the flood zone. ThatĢƵ very, very important, if you’re in a flood zone.”
SWC Properties agent Claudette Franks said many factors can impact the price a seller wants and what a buyer wants to spend, but the firm uses the sale price of comparable homes to set prices.
“We base prices on comparable houses sold in that area,” Franks said.
The price of a home outside of the county tends to be less than a comparable home in the county, Cavinee said.
“Buyers from out of the area are shocked to see our prices here,” Cavinee said. “ItĢƵ been that way since I’ve been a realtor.”
Franks said location is always a factor in pricing homes to sell.
Some people want to live closer to shopping centers and in certain school districts, and some want the open space offered in rural areas, Franks said.
Most homes for sale need at least some updating, but 70 percent of buyers want homes in move-in condition, Cavinee said.
Eugene Rosky Jr., an appraiser from Mount Pleasant who says he does about a third of his business in Fayette County, said sellers can ask any price, but buyers are limited to what they can afford.
“ThereĢƵ not a silver bullet kind of answer (to what impacts prices most),” Rosky said. “If it was easy to determine, we wouldn’t need appraisers.”
Location and curb appeal influence buyers most, Rosky said.
The condition rating that an appraiser gives impacts prices, he said. A leaky roof hurts the condition, but adjustments are not made for new roof, he said.
“By and large itĢƵ location,” Rosky said. “A beat-up house is helped if itĢƵ in a nice area. A nice house in a bad neighborhood has a lower value.”
If a house is priced correctly, it should sell in 60 days, he said.
Most buyers pay 93 percent of the asking price, Rosky said.

