New Geibel principal eager to make impact
A new school year will bring a new face to the head position at Geibel Catholic High School.
As a fresh coat of paint dries on Patricia NicklerĢƵ office walls, the new principal of the Connellsville school has a simple message: the only changes to the school will be improvements.
“I want our parents to know that the basic premise of the school won’t change no matter who the principal is. Our objective is to provide their children the opportunity to grow academically and in their faith,” said Nickler.
“While their child is here, they will be challenged to be the best version of themselves.”
The Roman Catholic Diocese of Greensburg announced NicklerĢƵ appointment to the position in May.
A first-time principal, she started in her new role earlier this month, replacing Don Favero, who retired at the end of last school year after serving as principal of Geibel since 2011.
In her short time at Geibel, Nickler has met with students attending STEM and performing arts camps and a cheerleader pancake breakfast to show support for her new students.
“Every kid I’ve met has been excited for the first day of school,” Nickler said. “It makes me assume that the teachers have made it an environment that students want to come back to.”
NicklerĢƵ primary goal at Geibel, she said, is to ensure the school maintains its current atmosphere, a familial one that both nurtures and challenges students.
“It seems like a community thatĢƵ really like a family. Any reservations I’ve had, the people here have really made me feel welcome and part of the community,” she said.
“The faculty I’ve met have been very helpful, knowledgeable and well-educated. I can tell they have a sincere interest in the students and their success.”
The appointment to Geibel is a homecoming of sorts for Nickler.
The Greene County native from Bobtown fled to the warm weather of Florida 32 years ago. She taught in Catholic schools there for the last 17 years.
A graduate of Mapletown High School, Nickler attended Penn State Fayette, The Eberly Campus before competing her bachelorĢƵ degree in finance at University Park.
After a long career as a stockbroker and portfolio manager, Nickler made the transition to teaching.
She began her Catholic education career in 1999 as a middle school mathematics teacher at St. Juliana Catholic School in West Palm Beach, Florida, before moving to All Saints Catholic School in Jupiter, Florida, where she spent 10 years as an advanced mathematics teacher.
Nickler holds a masterĢƵ degree in educational leadership with principalĢƵ certification from Barry University.
Dr. Maureen Marsteller, superintendent of Catholic schools for the diocese, said, “Mrs. Nickler identifies as a servant leader. Her pastor (Father Andrew Brierley of St. Luke Parish, Palm Springs, Florida) says she has contributed significantly to the Catholic culture of All Saints.”
With family in nearby Morgantown, West Virginia, Nickler decided it was time to return to southwestern Pennsylvania.
In her new role, she hopes to bring to Geibel ideas that will improve the ways students learn.
At a school that the diocese has pumped money into in recent years to improve technology offerings and create comfortable classrooms, Nickler plans to build on existing methods to help students reach their full potential.
She said she has already spoken to Marsteller about the prospect of adding Advanced Placement courses, and hopes to create learning spaces that will better utilize the schoolĢƵ technology to help students learn through collaboration.
“Learning is not sitting in rows reading a book anymore. ItĢƵ going on the Internet and finding information,” said Nickler, adding that the current generation of students primarily learns through images, collaboration and technology.
“ThatĢƵ the kinds of things I want to see here — kids working collaboratively and interactively.”
Geibel has 192 registered students for the upcoming school year, which is increase from past years, said Nickler.
Although the school is significantly smaller than the one where she last taught, she feels a small school atmosphere allows for better relationships between faculty and students.
“Geibel permeates the entire community here,” Nickler said. “Everyone I’ve met has been a Geibel graduate, or the husband or wife of a Geibel graduate, or a child of a Geibel graduate.
“ItĢƵ a gift to be here.”

