Charleston police chief speaks at Cal UĢƵ security conference
California University of PennsylvaniaĢƵ 11th annual Conference on Homeland and International Security focused on protecting places of worship and featured a retired police chief who served in Charleston, South Carolina, during the Mother Emmanuel AME Church shooting and its aftermath.
Gregory C. Mullen got his start as an assistant chief in Virginia Beach, but when he took the job in Charleston before the 2015 shooting that took the lives of nine people, he found a community with so much poverty and violence that people were afraid to go outside.
“It changed me. It changed me as a person,” said Mullen.
So, he said, he decided to change the community. Mullen said he strove to create relationships and partnerships in the community, building a culture with vision and purpose, putting himself out there to the people he served.
“The more open and vulnerable I was to people … the more I became a complete person,” said Mullen. “What I learned in Charleston is you don’t have to be hard.”
It was, he said, the work to connect with the cityĢƵ residents that helped him and his department during the shooting and its aftermath. The collaboration and cooperation meant residents worked with police instead of shying away during one of the cityĢƵ most difficult times, Mullen said.
Dylan Roof was the shooter. Mullen doesn’t say his name. He hasn’t in any speaking engagement heĢƵ done, he said, but he spoke of RoofĢƵ intention to spark a race war when he killed six women and three men, all black, at the church.
Mother Emmanuel is one of the most historical churches in the South and a symbol of black freedom. In 1822, it was burned to the ground by a slave revolt and rebuilt. In 1886, it was destroyed by an earthquake and rebuilt. In the 1960s, it was a focal point of the civil rights movement.
All of these things, it turned out, just made the church more of a target for Roof.
“He knew if he attacked Mother Emmanuel it would send a ripple across the black community,” Mullen said.
Self-radicalized for two years, Roof scouted the church for six months and made seven trips to Charleston, before eventually carrying out his attack on June 17, 2015, Mullen said.
Roof came to the church and asked to join in a Bible study class, where for 40 minutes he discussed verses with those there. After the class ended, he stood up for the prayer and began shooting. There were three survivors, including one Roof said he purposefully left alive to tell the tale. The other two were a woman who feigned death and laid atop her granddaughter to protect the 5-year-old.
Roof fled and was apprehended 14 days later in North Carolina, but that really was just the beginning, according to Mullen. The community needed to heal.
Officials set up a family assistance center. Police worked with the community during funerals, rallies and protests and during RoofĢƵ trial.
Mullen said the partnerships forged years before kicked in.
“Health and wellness impacts the entire community, not just the victims and their families. We need resources for the community because they are going to be suffering too,” he said.
A community rally of about 12,000 people of all races and walks of life helped move the community forward.
Mullen recalled one pastor who said Roof may have wanted to start a race war, but “what he started was a revival.”
Dr. Michael L. Hummel, a retired military police officer and an active municipal police officer in Charleroi and Monessen, also spoke at the conference. Hummel said protecting institutions of worship is a challenge.
Churches, he said, are considered suitable targets for shooters because they host open gatherings of unprotected people who feel they are secure.
“We have to train people to be vigilant and convince them that (potential threats are) real,” said Hummel, who is also a criminal justice and security studies professor at Cal U. “You are always going to have bad people – very bad people.”
Hummel said he believes churches should educate their clergy and church leadership, and appoint a security leader or committee. Having an emergency plan, even an informal one, will help leaders and congregants be prepared, he said.
Don’t be afraid to consult with law enforcement can help with those plans, Hummel said.
“Training is key. Training is everything. Everything is training,” said Hummel.
Hummel warned leaders that if using cameras and technology, make sure they are being monitored by someone who is trained. Otherwise, the footage is only good for evidence after the fact.
In closing, Hummel made a suggestion for church leaders.
“Pray to God,” he said, “then post a guard.”


