ĢƵ

close

Portrait of Greene judge Lou Dayich unveiled

By Garrett Neese 4 min read
1 / 5
Greene County Court Administrator Sheila Rode welcomes the crowd to a Law Day ceremony where the protrait of former judge Lou Dayich was unveiled. [Garrett Neese]
2 / 5
Lou Dayich, who served as president judge and Court of Common Pleas judge in Greene County before retiring at the end of 2025, looks at his new portrait in the Greene County Courthouse Friday. [Garrett Neese]
3 / 5
H. Terry Grimes, former president judge for Greene County, tells a story about recently retired judge Lou Dayich. [Garrett Neese]
4 / 5
Lou dayich, who served as president judge for Greene County until his term ended at the start of 2026, speaks to the crowd at the ceremony for the unveiling of his portrait at the Greene County Courthouse Friday. [Garrett Neese]
5 / 5
Greene County Commissioner Blair Zimmerman read a proclamation honoring May 1 as Law Day and Judge Dayich Appreciation Day. [Garrett Neese]

When he was sworn in as Court of Common Pleas judge 10 years ago, Lou Dayich likened it to a “passing of the baton.”

ItĢƵ a race thatĢƵ gone on in the same location since the current Greene County Courthouse was built in 1851.

“You can tell that when they built it, it wasn’t built for any one person, for any one case,” said Dayich, who finished his leg of the relay when his term ended at the start of 2026. “ItĢƵ really kind of a monument to justice. ItĢƵ nice that we have a place to settle our disputes peacefully.”

He was back in the courtroom Friday morning, as he unveiled his official portrait during a ceremony in Courtroom 1.

The photo was taken by Janice Morris, the wife of the late Greene County lawyer Charles Morris.

It joins a long procession of portraits of Greene County judges. DayichĢƵ image now hangs on the opposite wall from James Lindsey, who presided over a district that combined Greene with Washington and Fayette counties from 1861 to 1864.

FridayĢƵ ceremony was attended by county officials and members of the legal community who’d worked with Dayich in his many roles over the years: lawyer, public defender, district magistrate, Court of Common Pleas judge and eventually president judge, which he’d held for the last five years of his term.

“Your insight, your institutional knowledge, your legal knowledge and desire to do the right thing was a great asset to this court,” said Judge Jeffry Grimes, who picked up the baton from Dayich as president judge.

H. Terry Grimes, who spent 23 years on the bench before retiring as president judge in 2009, has known Dayich for 39 years, since he swore him into the Greene County Bar.

He never told Dayich at the time (“I didn’t want him to get a big head”), but he was an “excellent attorney.”

“He not only was knowledgeable in the law, but his main matter was understanding human nature and using common sense,” he said. “He knew when to advise a client, ‘Hey, we better do this.’ And he knew when to advise a client otherwise.”

Over the years, H. Terry Grimes became good friends with Dayich, who he praised as “a great storyteller.”

The only time he recalled seeing Dayich angry was when he found a defendant Dayich was representing guilty of stealing a piece of farm equipment.

At first, Grimes thought Dayich might be upset at his client, who had convinced him of his innocence, for misrepresenting the facts of the case.

As it turned out, he was mad at Grimes.

“He thought it was very unfair that I had familiarity with farm equipment and West Virginia geography, both of which were vital points in the facts of that case,” Grimes said. “But true to his nature, the next day, he was back to his jolly self, and I never saw him angry again.”

Greene County Commissioner Blair Zimmerman read a proclamation from the county board commemorating the day as Law Day, as well as Judge Dayich Appreciation Day.

Afterward, people walked over to get a closer look at the portrait, and stopped by to talk to to Dayich.

He said has seen how prospective jurors react to the portraits when they fill the room for jury selection. ItĢƵ a good gauge of how long judges last in the collective memory, he said.

By the time it gets to what former president judge Farley Toothman called “the moustache area,” people might draw blanks.

“When they come in, they’re like ‘I remember that judge, and I remember that judge,’ and then they go, ‘I don’t know who that guy is,'” Dayich said. “So for a little while, at least, people would probably remember that judge.”

CUSTOMER LOGIN

If you have an account and are registered for online access, sign in with your email address and password below.

NEW CUSTOMERS/UNREGISTERED ACCOUNTS

Never been a subscriber and want to subscribe, click the Subscribe button below.

Starting at $4.79/week.